Is Rancher going in the SUSE Box?

Doug Laird - July 10, 2020 - , , , , ,

SUSE’s $600 million (USD) acquisition of Rancher Labs means that the Kubernetes market is heading towards a major decision-point between freedom of choice and solutions tied to an enterprise Linux distribution and its agenda.

For a long time, Rancher has been telling customers that they’re committed to open source, and has claimed freedom of choice as a core part of their value proposition. But in hitching their steers to an OS-maker’s wagon, will they be turning their back on these principles? We think there’s ample reason for Rancher customers to be concerned, and for those evaluating and comparing enterprise Kubernetes solutions to be cautious.

SUSE’s CaaS and App platforms, after all, both ran only on SUSE products. Their strategy — just like Red Hat’s with OpenShift — seems pretty clear: build a tall Kubernetes enterprise application stack — each layer locked into the one below it, all grounded on an enterprise Linux spin that they control.

Now, the risk to Rancher users is that SUSE will double down on this strategy, copying Red Hat, Canonical, and other Linux providers in closely coupling Kubernetes offerings to their core OS platform. Cloud-hosted Kubernetes service providers have done this too, of course, though in different ways.

(In fact, this leaves Mirantis as the only leading enterprise Kubernetes solution provider still unambiguously committed to providing a zero lock-in platform and empowering customer freedom of choice.)

How’s this likely to roll out?

For a while, current Rancher users will be unaffected: they’ll keep running the platform on any OS Rancher currently supports. Gradually, though, economics and profit motives will likely urge creation of hard dependencies between Rancher and SUSE Linux Enterprise Server, gradually limiting customer choice and promoting lock-in.

How could this look? Lots of small changes, with valuable bits moving around from place to place. Red Hat does this a lot: for example, they implemented FIPS 140-2 compliance (use of NIST-certified ciphers for traffic encryption within nodes) in RHEL, rather than OpenShift, locking platform and OS tighter than ever together for users who need this level of encryption.

What will it mean for Rancher users, if it happens? First, there’s cost. They’ll need to pay for the OS their platform runs on, just like you can’t run OpenShift without running Red Hat Enterprise Linux. Every new node adds a fixed (or, on cloud platforms, recurring) charge, plus maybe the additional cost of skilling-up to support a new flavor of Linux. This may not sit well with top developers and IT ops talent, who tend to want control over the operating systems they work with and depend on.

Then there are roadblocks. For example, you might be barred from deploying Kubernetes on certain platform footprints, simply because they can’t run the required host OS. 

Will all this happen to Rancher users? Only time will tell — for now, though, we know for sure that lock-in is profitable for (some) vendors, and that others are strongly compelled to try to duplicate that success. We saw this with OS-vendor-driven OpenStack distributions, for example, which became more and more dependent on proprietary OS features and associated services. We see it now with Kubernetes offerings from Red Hat, Canonical, and similar quasi-proprietary spins from every cloud provider.

If this concerns you, please get in touch, and let’s discuss the cost and productivity benefits of opting for Kubernetes freedom of choice.

banner-img
From Virtualization to Containerization
Learn how to move from monolithic to microservices in this free eBook
Download Now
Radio Cloud Native – Week of May 11th, 2022

Every Wednesday, Nick Chase and Eric Gregory from Mirantis go over the week’s cloud native and industry news. This week they discussed: Docker Extensions Artificial Intelligence shows signs that it's reaching the common person Google Cloud TPU VMs reach general availability Google buys MobileX, folds into Google Cloud NIST changes Palantir is back, and it's got a Blanket Purchase Agreement at the Department of Health and Human …

Radio Cloud Native – Week of May 11th, 2022
Where do Ubuntu 20.04, OpenSearch, Tungsten Fabric, and more all come together? In the latest Mirantis Container Cloud releases!

In the last several weeks we have released two updates to Mirantis Container Cloud - versions 2.16 and 2.17, which bring a number of important changes and enhancements. These are focused on both keeping key components up to date to provide the latest functionality and security fixes, and also delivering new functionalities for our customers to take advantage of in …

Where do Ubuntu 20.04, OpenSearch, Tungsten Fabric, and more all come together? In the latest Mirantis Container Cloud releases!
Monitoring Kubernetes costs using Kubecost and Mirantis Kubernetes Engine [Transcript]

Cloud environments & Kubernetes are becoming more and more expensive to operate and manage. In this demo-rich workshop, Mirantis and Kubecost demonstrate how to deploy Kubecost as a Helm chart on top of Mirantis Kubernetes Engine. Lens users will be able to visualize their Kubernetes spend directly in the Lens desktop application, allowing users to view spend and costs efficiently …

Monitoring Kubernetes costs using Kubecost and Mirantis Kubernetes Engine [Transcript]
FREE EBOOK!
Service Mesh for Mere Mortals
A Guide to Istio and How to Use Service Mesh Platforms
DOWNLOAD
Technical training
Learn Kubernetes & OpenStack from Deployment Experts
Prep for certification!
View schedule
Mirantis Webstore
Purchase Kubernetes support
SHOP NOW